Choosing the Right Formula by Panel on Formula Allocations, Committee on National

By Panel on Formula Allocations, Committee on National Statistics, National Research Council, Thomas B. Jabine, Thomas A. Louis, Allen L. Schirm

The workshop used to be an instantaneous outgrowth of a prior research by way of the CNSTAT Panel on Estimates of Poverty for Small Geographic parts. That panel, validated below a 1994 act of Congress, started its paintings with a truly particular undertaking: to guage the suitability of the U.S. Census Bureau's small-area estimates of bad school-age teenagers to be used within the allocation of cash to counties and faculty districts below name I of the undemanding and Secondary schooling Act.

In engaging in their project, panel contributors got here to achieve that the homes of knowledge assets and statistical systems used to provide formulation estimates, interacting with formulation positive aspects comparable to thresholds and hold-harmless provisions, can produce results that won't were expected or meant. It additionally turned obvious that there's a trade-off among the pursuits of offering an inexpensive quantity of balance in investment from twelve months to the following and redirecting cash to varied jurisdictions as actual wishes switch. in a single example, for instance, the once a year appropriation incorporated a one hundred pc hold-harmless provision, making sure that no recipient might obtain below the 12 months earlier than. in spite of the fact that, there has been no elevate within the overall appropriation, with the end result that new estimates exhibiting alterations within the distribution of software wishes throughout parts had no impression at the allocations.

Choosing definitely the right Formula presents an account of the shows and discussions on the workshop. the 1st 3 chapters conceal the review, case experiences, and methodological periods, respectively. bankruptcy four summarizes the problems mentioned within the roundtable and concluding periods, with emphasis at the id of questions that would be addressed in a panel study.

Show description

By Panel on Formula Allocations, Committee on National Statistics, National Research Council, Thomas B. Jabine, Thomas A. Louis, Allen L. Schirm

The workshop used to be an instantaneous outgrowth of a prior research by way of the CNSTAT Panel on Estimates of Poverty for Small Geographic parts. That panel, validated below a 1994 act of Congress, started its paintings with a truly particular undertaking: to guage the suitability of the U.S. Census Bureau's small-area estimates of bad school-age teenagers to be used within the allocation of cash to counties and faculty districts below name I of the undemanding and Secondary schooling Act.

In engaging in their project, panel contributors got here to achieve that the homes of knowledge assets and statistical systems used to provide formulation estimates, interacting with formulation positive aspects comparable to thresholds and hold-harmless provisions, can produce results that won't were expected or meant. It additionally turned obvious that there's a trade-off among the pursuits of offering an inexpensive quantity of balance in investment from twelve months to the following and redirecting cash to varied jurisdictions as actual wishes switch. in a single example, for instance, the once a year appropriation incorporated a one hundred pc hold-harmless provision, making sure that no recipient might obtain below the 12 months earlier than. in spite of the fact that, there has been no elevate within the overall appropriation, with the end result that new estimates exhibiting alterations within the distribution of software wishes throughout parts had no impression at the allocations.

Choosing definitely the right Formula presents an account of the shows and discussions on the workshop. the 1st 3 chapters conceal the review, case experiences, and methodological periods, respectively. bankruptcy four summarizes the problems mentioned within the roundtable and concluding periods, with emphasis at the id of questions that would be addressed in a panel study.

Show description

Read Online or Download Choosing the Right Formula PDF

Best public finance books

Debt Games: Strategic Interaction in International Debt Rescheduling

This publication explains the numerous edition that has emerged through the years and throughout instances in overseas debt rescheduling up to now 100 and seventy years. in accordance with a singular situational idea of bargaining, Professor Aggarwal's learn offers a mode to infer actors' payoffs in several bargaining events to improve "debt games," that are then used to foretell negotiating results.

Green Accounting in Europe — Four case studies

Traditional fiscal debts, which degree Gross nationwide Product (GNP)and comparable symptoms of nationwide functionality, don't absolutely enable for the damages brought on to the surroundings during generating and eating items and providers. Nor do they totally account for the truth that a few assets are being depleted in attaining the dwelling criteria that we get pleasure from this day.

The Economics of Special Privilege and Rent Seeking

Because the reader of this booklet most likely already is familiar with, i've got dedicated loads of time to the subject that's, quite regrettably, named lease looking. hire looking, using assets in truly decreasing overall product even if reaping benefits a few minority, is, regrettably, a huge task of such a lot governments.

Extra resources for Choosing the Right Formula

Example text

Schirm concluded his presentation by discussing opportunities for further improvements in the estimates as new and better data become available over the next few years. New data sources will include the 2000 census, the ACS, and possibly the Survey of Income and Program Participation, especially if it becomes a data source for official poverty statistics. In addition, Congress has appropriated funds for increasing sample sizes to improve the precision of CPS state estimates of children lacking health insurance, with the likely effect of also increasing the precision of state estimates of persons eligible for the WIC program.

One thing that stood out very clearly was the extent to which using the alternative formulas would cause funds to be transferred from the large, more urban states to the smaller, rural states. Summarizing what was learned from the RAND study, Adams offered the following conclusions: • It would be possible to do a better job of defining the population and cost-of-services components of the formula. These improvements would matter, with funds being shifted from larger, urban states to smaller, rural states.

A key difficulty is that there are no nationally consistent administrative data available to use for the kind of modeling that is done at the county level. , 1995) in proportion to each district’s share of poor schoolage children in the 1990 census. For districts whose boundaries changed between 1990 and the estimation year, census data by block were used to obtain census estimates for the districts as defined in the estimation year. 4 The average absolute difference in the estimates for poor school-age children was 22 percent, roughly double that which had been observed for the county estimates.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.74 of 5 – based on 19 votes